50 Ways to Use Up Leftover Pumpkin Puree

Welcome to 52 Kitchen Adventures, your source for creative & delicious desserts! See my Recipe Index for more. Don't want to miss another recipe? Subscribe via RSS or email.

50 delicious ways to use up leftover pumpkin puree

Does this happen to you – you open up a can of pumpkin, bake something with it, and then end up with a little leftover? Every time I bake with pumpkin, I seem to have a little bit left. Sometimes it’s a few tablespoons from a 15-oz. can, sometimes it’s much more from one of those huge cans or when I roast my own pumpkin. I hate to throw away any of this delicious squash, especially when there are so many yummy things you can make with it.

I’ve gathered 50 (yes, fifty!) delicious solutions to this problem so none of us have to throw away any pumpkin ever again! Recipes range from 1 tablespoon to 2 cups of leftover pumpkin, with a special emphasis on a small amount of leftovers, since that happens so often with those small cans of pumpkin puree.

There are sweet and savory recipes included, and each has the amount of pumpkin listed so you can pick out exactly what you need without clicking through to each recipe. I can’t wait to try some of these – some are truly unique (like DIY pumpkin liqueur), some sound amazingly delicious (pumpkin cinnamon streusel pancakes anyone?), and some will definitely come in handy (such as a single-serving pumpkin muffin).

A Little Leftover Pumpkin:

1. Frozen pumpkin cubes from Crunchy Creamy Sweet (1+ tablespoons)
2. Single-serving pumpkin muffin from Happy Herbivore (2 tablespoons)
3. Pumpkin spice cocktail from Yumsugar (2 tablespoons)
4. Pumpkin pie-tini from Blisstree (2 tablespoons)
5. Pumpkin pie milkshake from A Cozy Kitchen (2 tablespoons)
6. Pumpkin granola from The Wannabe Chef (2 tablespoons)
7. Pumpkin pie cocoa from Pass the Sushi (3 tablespoons)
8. Pumpkin spice macarons from The Marvelous Misadventures of a Foodie (3 tablespoons)
9. DIY pumpkin liqueur from Serious Eats (3 tablespoons)
10. Pumpkin pie creamer from 52 Kitchen Adventures (3 tablespoons)
11. Pumpkin spice syrup from Doo Wacka Doodles (3 tablespoons)
12. Pumpkin mocha latte from Fast Paleo (1/4 cup)
13. Pumpkin gingerbread cookies from Ben Starr (1/4 cup)
14. Pumpkin biscotti from Dessert for Two (1/4 cup)
15. Pumpkin chai tea latte from Fast Paleo (1/4 cup)
16. Pumpkin spice latte from Love Veggies and Yoga (1/4 cup)
17. Pumpkin honey cornbread from The Comfort of Cooking (1/4 cup)
18. Pumpkin pie sugar scrub from Sugar and Charm Blog (1/4 cup)
19. Spicy chocolate pumpkin milkshake from Serious Eats (1/4 cup + 1 tablespoon)
20. Pumpkin pancakes from How To: Simplify (1/4 cup + 2 tablespoons)

Some Leftover Pumpkin:

21. Pumpkin cinnamon rolls with pumpkin spice glaze from Knead to Cook (1/2 cup)
22. Pumpkin brownies from Blog Chef (1/2 cup)
23. Pumpkin smoothie from Healthful Pursuit (1/2 cup)
24. Pumpkin spice cake pops from the CSI Project (1/2 cup)
25. Pumpkin cinnamon streusel pancakes from Two Peas and their Pod (1/2 cup)
27. Pumpkin pie fudge from Family Bites (1/2 cup)
28. Pumpkin pie margarita from Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (1/2 cup)
29. Chocolate pumpkin cheesecake brownies from Jo Cooks (1/2 cup)
30. Pumpkin mousse with crunchy gingersnaps and maple crème fraîche from Oprah (1/2 cup plus 2 tablespoons)
31. Pumpkin cream cheese from Better Homes and Gardens (1/2 cup)
32. Pumpkin risotto from Lauren’s Latest (1/2 cup)
33. Pumpkin garlic knots from Handle the Heat (1/2 cup)
34. Healthy bacon and pumpkin pasta from Pinch of Yum (1/2 cup)
35. Spicy pumpkin hummus from Once Upon a Cutting Board (1/2 cup)
36. Pumpkin body butter from Care2 (1/2 cup)


A Lot of Leftover Pumpkin:

37. Pumpkin pie oatmeal from Good Life Eats (3/4 cup)
38. Pumpkin bread from Simply Recipes (1 cup)
39. Pumpkin bars from Heavenly Homemakers (1 cup)
40. Pumpkin flan from Bitchin’ Camero (1 cup)
41. Soft pumpkin spice cookies from 52 Kitchen Adventures (1 cup)
42. Pumpkin spice cake from Joy of Baking (1 cup)
43. Crunchy pumpkin quinoa cereal from Blissful (1 cup)
44. Pumpkin mac and cheese from Inspired Taste (1 cup)
45. Pumpkin apple walnut harvest rice from Healthy Happy Life (1 cup)
46. Savory pumpkin pizza dough from The Cooking Photographer (1 cup)
47. Pumpkin pomegranate couscous from Little Bitty Bakes (1 cup)
48. Chocolate pumpkin marble cake from Back to the Cutting Board (1 1/4 cup)
49. Pumpkin marmalade from Better Homes and Gardens (2 cups)
50. Pumpkin Spice Cupcakes with Browned Butter Frosting from 52 Kitchen Adventures (2 cups)

17 Responses to “50 Ways to Use Up Leftover Pumpkin Puree”
  1. Leanne @ Healthful Pursuit writes:

    Hi Stephanie – thanks for the feature! You’ve created quite the amazing roundup here, I’m impressed :)

  2. Stephanie writes:

    Thanks Leanne! It was a lot of fun to put together.

  3. Averie @ Averie Cooks writes:

    Thanks for including my latte (#16) in yoru roundup. WOW – you have tons of ideas here and this is a great resource post! Thanks for compiling it!

  4. Christina @ Be mindful. Be human. writes:

    Thanks Stephanie! I love that you included the amount of pumpkin each recipe needed. Now I don’t have to worry about having my pumpkin rot in the fridge and have to open a new one every time I need to make something with pumpkins. Can’t wait to try some of these recipes.
    Christina @ Be mindful. Be human. recently posted Scary Halloween Pasta

  5. Anna @ Crunchy Creamy Sweet writes:

    Ooooh, LOVE this round-up! So many great pumpkin recipes! Thank you for including my frozen cubes, Stephanie! :)
    Anna @ Crunchy Creamy Sweet recently posted Frozen Pumpkin Cubes & 10 Ways to Use Them

  6. Joanne @ Inspired Taste writes:

    Thank you so much for including our pumpkin mac and cheese! What a great collection!
    Joanne @ Inspired Taste recently posted Soft Ginger Cookies with Chocolate Chips

  7. Nicole @ The Marvelous Misadventures of a Foodie writes:

    Stephanie! This is such an awesome roundup – I seriously love that you included how much pumpkin each recipe needs! I know for a fact that this will come in handy, I cringe at the though of throwing away that last couple tablespoons of pumpkin the bottom of the can – it’s like tossing out liquid gold ;)

    Thanks for including my Pumpkin Spice Macarons in the round up too :)
    Nicole @ The Marvelous Misadventures of a Foodie recently posted Currently: October 2012

  8. Rebecca writes:

    I just stirred some into my granola recipe this morning with some pumpkin pie spice. Yum!
    Rebecca recently posted Happy Halloween Socks

  9. the wicked noodle writes:

    Brilliant, Steph! Great post!
    the wicked noodle recently posted steak & poblano chili

  10. Alessandra writes:

    Cool, although we don’t really have pumpkin puree in New Zealand (we need to make it from whole pumpkins) so it is unlikely that I have leftovers… still, you never know, thanks for the ideas.

    Alessandra recently posted Stuffed mushrooms (pity they shrink so much!), Taste magazine, and a story about quail eggs and great service

  11. Lia writes:

    I have been looking for this list all my life. Thank you! :)
    Lia recently posted Cute bread tag magnets

  12. Listly List - Pumpkin Recipes writes:

    […] 50 Ways to Use Up Leftover Pumpkin | 52 Kitchen Adventures […]

  13. DessertForTwo writes:

    What a great roundup! Thanks for including me :)

  14. Pumpkin, pumpkin everywhere… | Everything In Between writes:

    […] enough, the blog 52 Kitchen Adventures created a list of 50 Ways to Use Up Leftover Pumpkin Puree! Here are the recipes from this list I’ve tried so […]

  15. Pumpkin, pumpkin everywhere | Et Cetera writes:

    […] different ways to use it up. Conveniently enough, the blog 52 Kitchen Adventures created a list of 50 Ways to Use Up Leftover Pumpkin Puree! Here are the recipes from this list I’ve tried so […]

  16. Uses for That Pumpkin You Picked up at Tulsa's Farmers Market writes:

    […] it to a mouthwatering and healthy chicken and poblano soup. If you aren’t much of a soup fan, you can also use your pumpkin in milkshakes, creamer, syrup, cornbread, pancakes, pasta, and even hummus. You can also use it as […]

  17. DIY Pumpkin Spice Oreos - 52 Kitchen Adventures | 52 Kitchen Adventures writes:

    […] P.S. If you need some ideas for using up the remainder of your pumpkin, here are 50 ways to use up leftover pumpkin puree. […]

Leave a Reply